Friday, February 18, 2011

Owl Ethics - Spotted Owl Versus the Barred Owl

Spotted Owl - USFWS
 Spotted Owl (photo by USFWS)


The northern spotted owl is in the news again, this time as linked to the death of 1200-1500 barred owls.  This summer, the USFWS may release in an environemental impact statement their reccomendation to kill barred owls. This is in response to the increasing range of the native barred owl who pushes out the the endangered spotted owl. 

"It's a wrenching decision that splits wildlife biologists and environmentalists. Killing one native animal to benefit another is such a leap that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service hired an environmental ethicist to guide its discussions."

"There's no winner in that debate," says Bob Sallinger, conservation director with the Portland Audubon Society

Making difficult decisions is not new in wildlife management and conservation.  Federal workers have killed comorants, terns, and seals to protect salmon and in Puerto Rico, Red-tailed Hawks are killed to reduce their predation on the endangered Puerto Rican Parrot.

As a wildlife veterinarian I have been faced with the moral dilemmas present in this work and have been severely challenged as I wade with others through the ethical morass of wildlife care and management.

For this reason I recently finished a chapter, Wandering Through the Wilderness of Ethical Discourse, in the book Topics in Wildlife Medicine: Ethical Considerations in Wildlife Medicine. This book will be published by the National Wildlife Rehabilitators Association (NWRA).  In it I suggest that our lives are full of tragic decisions and that to care for ourselves and others we must improve our skills in ethical deliberation, and we need to do it together.

 For this aim I am traveling to the NWRA 2011 Symposium in Albany, NY next week to give a seminar on Compassionate Rehabilitation.  My hope is that we can learn and practice together how to talk to one another so that we use our community resources to arrive at the best decisions to help the most species and individuals.

One way I suggest we do this is to practice Needs Based Ethics.  In this approach we do not say that one species or individual is of more worth than another.  Instead we bring to the table a deep appreciation of the worth and dignity of all of life.  What guides our discussion is discerning and empathizing with the needs of all species and individuals within a given situation.  By keeping our hearts and minds open, which I admit is difficult given the loss of life resulting from our daily activities, choices, and conservation management decisions, we can come up with creative solutions. 

In the end, not all beauty may be preserved in the way we'd like.  We may howl over owls, but not at each other through the tactics of shame and blame.  In the end, we will have one another with which to mourn and can claim that at least we did not turn from the splendor that is ever present to us in owl, human, tree, and fish.   

  Barred Owl


  1. I am in fact pleased to read this webpage posts which includes plenty of helpful facts, thanks for providing these information.

  2. For instance, our chinz may be traced back through variois family connections and chaanges of name to the "India Chinces" brought over from India by the East India Trading Company. It can be cleaned off the baby's feet with only a wet washcloth. They save time and can overall add to the importance of documents when you are doing things professionally. If you use stationary to start making birthday cards or scrapbooks, undertake learning methods in die cutting, punching, or utilize stickers to build extra patterns to set off your images or pictures. He was accompanied by on of his employees, a friendly young chap called Kouki. Now a days even people use rubber stamps as household item like, to stamp your name at gifts or card or letters instead of writing with them.

  3. A great way to build a 2,000-5,000 email list of local, affluent consumers who are in need of your personal training business products and services, AND a powerful REASON WHY to contact your ideal strategic alliance partners, build relationships with them, and help them grow their business (and yours). A classroom needs to be flexible, so it can quickly and easily be rearranged. Although you could retain a lawyer for the purpose of negotiation, it can be a costly alternative over time, and in some instances as a business owner you may want to work with important business contacts personally rather than working through a third party. The quality of the human resources of an enterprise becomes the critical distinguishing factor among firms, and as such, firms compete with others to attract and retain talent. They make every superior in organization responsible for training which invariably results in learning updates either in technology, methodology or behavior. Many of you may feel like a headless chicken not knowing how to grow your business online or start your home based business. rule #3:Look After Your Customers and Your Customers Will Look After You,.

  4. It is always good that someone is continuously looking over your shoulder and wwill always push you tto do more ' to do better. Some of the leading engineering colleges in Punjab are SBS College of Engineering and Technology in Ferozpur, Dr. Placing in effort in the incorrect parts is counterproductive and may perhaps not be obtaining you the outcomes you want. If the client spends sufficient time on 'the being' rather than 'the doing' then action will automatically fall out of the conversation and will be lead by the client. However, they are not the only league looking for talented young players. Talk about what is most important to you during each session.

  5. If you are suffering from breakup depression you should not feel bad about seeking out your friends for support to help you get through this hard time. Place copies of your circular on bulletin boards throughout your community, such as in coin-operated laundries, grocery stores, barber shops, etc. For more information on local scrapbooking events, find a comprehensive calendar here. This seems like an obvious topic, but a lot of sales managers and people forget about this. The primary purpose of t-shirts is to create an identity of the wearer. Someone said I was "nerve problem", this, I just want to do not understand. Contact other dealers and state you will print and mail their circulars for this price with no conflicting ads on the back.